Skip to content
DataPublished: 5 min read

Series: Counting tender notices · Part 2

"ISMS or equivalent" in Japanese tender notices: what counts as equivalent if you hold no certificate

Written by Minako Miyoshi, Columnist

Reviewed by Motoki Arai, CEO & Representative Director

The short answer

  • Of 445 notices that mention ISMS or PrivacyMark, 113 (25.4%) state in the same clause a way to qualify without the certificate. That is about one in four.
  • There are three routes: showing equivalent management or measures in documents (68), submitting documents that show your security organisation (30), and submitting the result of IPA's self-assessment (16).
  • It depends heavily on the buyer: 36.1% for incorporated administrative agencies and similar bodies, 6% for local governments. Without a certificate, local-government work is all but closed.
445
notices mentioning ISMS or PrivacyMark
25.4%
offer a route without the certificate
36.1%
among agencies and similar bodies
6%
among local governments
Contents
  1. Picking up from last time
  2. One notice in four offers another route
  3. Type 1: show equivalent management in documents (68)
  4. Type 2: submit documents showing the organisation (30)
  5. Type 3: submit IPA's self-assessment result (16)
  6. Documents to have ready
  7. Check before you bid
  8. Method and limits
  9. FAQ
  10. Sources

Picking up from last time

In the previous article we reported that one in five information-system tender notices names ISMS or PrivacyMark. Some of them read as if the certificate were optional: "holds ISMS certification, or carries out equivalent information-security management."

We are a company that has not yet been through its ISMS audit. If there are tenders we can enter before the certificate arrives, we want to know. So we checked, in the wording of the notices, how many of these "equivalent" clauses exist and what they ask for.

One notice in four offers another route

Of the 445 notices that mention ISMS or PrivacyMark, 113 (25.4%) state an alternative in the same clause. Split by type of buyer, the difference is plain.

Share of notices offering a route without the certificate, by buyer type
  • Agencies and national universities36.1%

    90 of 249

  • National ministries30.4%

    14 of 46

  • Local governments6%

    9 of 149

Routes offered (a notice offering more than one is counted under each)
  • Show equivalent management or measures in documents68
  • Submit documents showing the security organisation (a certificate also accepted)30
  • Submit the result of IPA's self-assessment16

A similar phrase, "ISMS or an equivalent certification" (38 notices), only means another certificate will do. It does not help a company with no certificate at all, and is not included in the 113.

Type 1: show equivalent management in documents (68)

The most common type; the Japan Science and Technology Agency (JST) accounts for 43 of them. JST spells out what equivalent means: an information-security policy has been established; a management organisation is in place; and risk assessment, the controls that follow from it, internal audit and training are carried out under documented procedures.

The Information-technology Promotion Agency (IPA) says what to submit if you hold no certificate: documents showing that equivalent measures are applied in actual work, such as rules on information management and security and operating procedures. A Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism notice for a system modification likewise accepted the management structure, operating rules and procedures.

Among local governments this type was rare; Chiba City was one of the few. Its notice for a national pension system asked for ISO 27001 certification or an equivalent information-security management system.

Type 2: submit documents showing the organisation (30)

All 30 came from the Japan Atomic Energy Agency. What it asks for is not the certificate but documents proving that information-security management is in place. An ISO/IEC 27001 or ISMS certificate is listed as one acceptable example.

The difference from Type 1 is which comes first. Type 1 says: the certificate, or failing that, the substance. Type 2 says: documents showing the substance, and a certificate will also do. For a company without the certificate, Type 2 is the more direct way in.

Type 3: submit IPA's self-assessment result (16)

Found in notices from the Forestry Agency and from the Ministry of Agriculture's Kanto regional office and veterinary assay laboratory. Three forms of proof are listed and any one will do: a certificate such as ISO/IEC 27001, a certificate such as PrivacyMark, or a confirmation of a self-assessment using IPA's Information Security Measures Benchmark.

The self-assessment has a bar: an average of 4 across all items, with no item below maturity level 2, as the notices state. You score yourself, but you cannot submit it unless you can back up each answer when asked.

Documents to have ready

Line up what the three types ask for and they nearly coincide. From the wording of the notices, six things:

  1. An information-security policy
  2. A chart of the organisation (who is responsible, who can access what)
  3. Risk-assessment results and the list of measures decided in response
  4. Rules on information management and security, and operating procedures
  5. Internal audit records
  6. Training records

This is very nearly what an ISMS audit looks at. We are preparing the same set for our own audits in February and March 2027. What you learn by doing it is that items 5 and 6 take time: audits and training leave records only after they have actually happened. To be ready for a tender, schedule them before you finish writing the rules.

Check before you bid

  • The buyer decides whether something is equivalent. Ask what will suffice while the question period is open.
  • Conditions may be written in the tender document or specification even when the notice text is silent.
  • The same buyer words things differently from one tender to the next. JST also published notices asking for the certificate only.
  • Local-government work offers almost no alternative route. Until the certificate arrives, agencies and national bodies are the realistic place to look.

Method and limits

  • The source is the same set of notices as the previous article (November 2025 to October 2026; the 445 that mention ISMS or PrivacyMark out of 2,181 information-system notices).
  • We took the text from 60 characters before to 260 characters after each mention of a certificate and sorted it by phrases such as "equivalent management / measures / organisation", "if not certified", "a certificate is also acceptable" and "measures benchmark".
  • The sorting is mechanical and will still contain errors. We read ten notices we had picked up and ten we had not, and removed the false matches we found (for example, sentences about a cloud certification). Treat the counts as a guide.
  • Conditions written outside the notice text (in tender documents or specifications) are not counted.

FAQ

What does "or equivalent" mean in "ISMS or equivalent"?
It depends on the buyer, but most often it means actually carrying out a policy, a management organisation, risk assessment, internal audit and training under documented procedures. JST writes this out in its notices. Sometimes it only means another certificate will do, so read the wording.
How many notices can a company without ISMS enter?
Of 445 notices mentioning ISMS or PrivacyMark, 113 (25.4%) state an alternative: 36.1% for agencies and 6% for local governments. Notices that do not mention a certificate at all are outside this count.
What documents do you need to bid as equivalent?
From the wording of the notices: an information-security policy, an organisation chart, risk-assessment results with the measures decided, rules and operating procedures, internal audit records and training records. The buyer decides what suffices, so ask during the question period.

Sources

  1. Public procurement information portal (SME Agency)
  2. JST: research project management system database operation (Jan 2026)
  3. IPA: cloud service and landing-zone build (AWS) (Nov 2025)
  4. MLIT: construction-related business registration system modification (Mar 2026)
  5. Chiba City: national pension system migration (Jul 2026)
  6. JAEA: maintenance of the tender information publication system (Jan 2026)
  7. Forestry Agency: mountain disaster survey application operation (Feb 2026)
  8. Information Security Measures Benchmark (IPA)

Links to individual notices point to the copies kept on the public procurement information portal, because the original pages on buyers' sites are taken down once the posting period ends.

Change log

  • — Published

If you spot an error in the numbers or the text, please let us know through the contact form. We will check, correct it, and record the change here.

Series

Counting tender notices

A series that checks, by counting tender notices one by one, what stands between a small company and public-sector IT work in Japan.

  1. Part 1Do you need ISO 27001 to bid on public-sector IT work in Japan? We counted 2,181 tender notices
  2. Part 2"ISMS or equivalent" in Japanese tender notices: what counts as equivalent if you hold no certificate(this article)
  3. Part 3A new company starts at grade D. How many national IT tenders in Japan can it enter?(coming November 22, 2026)
  4. Part 4The track-record wall: how many Japanese public IT tenders require prior experience(coming November 23, 2026)
  5. Part 5How many days from tender notice to deadline? Preparation time in 1,566 Japanese public IT tenders(coming November 25, 2026)
  6. Part 6How many AI and generative-AI tenders do Japanese public bodies publish, and for what? Counting 2,181 IT notices(coming November 27, 2026)
  7. Part 7How often is the proposal scored, not just the price? Award methods in 2,181 Japanese public IT tenders(coming November 30, 2026)
  8. Part 8ISMAP and Government Cloud conditions in Japanese public IT tenders: rarely asked of the bidder, while cloud-vendor certification is the real hurdle(coming December 2, 2026)
  9. Part 9Local-office requirements in Japanese municipal IT tenders: one notice in five, while seven in ten national notices come from Tokyo(coming December 4, 2026)
  10. Part 10Electronic or paper bids? Counting how Japanese public IT tenders must be submitted, and when briefings are mandatory(coming December 7, 2026)

About the author

Illustration of Minako Miyoshi, columnist at System Solutions Inc.

Minako Miyoshi

System Solutions Inc., Columnist

After working in the systems division at KDDI, Minako became a public elementary school teacher. She has used generative AI since 2022. For our columns she writes from public data and interviews with our CEO, Motoki Arai.

Reviewed by Motoki Arai, CEO & Representative Director
Checks the method behind the numbers and the text before publication.

More insights

DataCounting tender notices Part 18 min read

Do you need ISO 27001 to bid on public-sector IT work in Japan? We counted 2,181 tender notices

We counted 2,181 Japanese public-sector tender notices for information-system work published from November 2025 to October 2026. ISMS (ISO/IEC 27001) or PrivacyMark appears in 445 of them (20.4%). Here is how the requirement is worded, and when you can take part without a certificate.

Minako MiyoshiRead
20.4%
mention ISMS or PrivacyMark
76%
of those, satisfied by ISMS alone

Questions about bidding or ISMS?

We are going through the same preparation ourselves. Ask us alongside any software project you have in mind.

Initial consultation and quotes are free

Hamamatsucho Diamond Bldg. 2F, 2-2-15 Hamamatsucho, Minato-ku, Tokyo 105-0013, Japan